Sunday, November 8, 2015
The Secret History of Wonder Woman by Jill Lepore
Sunday, April 13, 2014
The Age of Edison by Ernest Freeburg
Friday, December 21, 2012
Superman versus the Ku Klux Klan by Rick Bowers
Wednesday, October 31, 2012
Men of Tomorrow by Gerard Jones
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
The Ten-Cent Plague by David Hajdu
Earlier this year, the last of the major comics publishers to use the Comics Code Authority dropped it in favor of their own rating standards. The seal of approval was one almost ubiquitous on newsstand comics. It lingered as sale shifted to comic book stores and older readers.
What led to the industry self-censorship represented by the little square seal is an interesting combination of social, political, and economic forces in American history. David Hajdu tells the story. (When The Ten-Cent Plague was published, major comics publishers were still using the seal.)
When comic strips first appeared in newspapers, the intent was to make the papers more appealing to the lower classes and immigrants who might not speak English, or even read. These cartoons appealed to the interest, problems and culture of this audience, along with other minorities, often thumbing their noses at the cultural establishment, the wealthy, political elites and others who had or represented power. As you might expect, the funnies had many detractors among the defenders of decent society.
This same countercultural element was transferred to comic books when they were invented in the 1930s. By the post-war years of the 1950s, the main countercultural was youth. People had been criticizing comics for their possible effects on children almost from the start, but the growing concern about juvenile delinquency (and possibly Communism) led to a successful campaign against comics. Rock and roll hadn’t been invented, so there wasn’t much else to blame.
Actually, a lot of the more reasonable explorations of the connections between comics reading and juvenile delinquency found it to be tenuous if it existed it all (delinquents read comics, but so did nearly every kid who could get an occasional dime). Detractors of comics thought they had evidence enough, especially Frederic Wertham, who’s Seduction of the Innocent added a sense of scientific respectability to the anti-comics camp.
The comics publishers reacted to save their industry from the wave of parental discontent and pending legislation. The Comics Code was a self-censorship standard like the film industries Hays Code, except much more restrictive. The code, and the forces that led up to it, almost killed the comics industry. It mostly eliminated the crime and horror comics that inspired the most ire through their excesses.
While Hajdu agrees that the crime and horror comics of the 1940s and early 1950s often had material that was unsuitable for children, he finds the roots of the anti-comics movement to be in the fundamental shift in culture between generations that occurred during the cold war. He also exhibits a lot of sympathy for the writers and artists that created comics, some of whom who left the arts altogether after the industry contracted.
Hajdu’s style is journalistic, like other works of popular history. The bibliography is extensive for those who are looking to make a study of comics. There is a touch of humor, which is bound to come up given the sometime goofy nature of comics and the ironies that abounded in the arguments both for and against the medium.
If you’re interested in this book, you may also be interested in
The Golden Age of DC Comics by Daniels, Kid and Spear
Stan Lee by Jordan Raphael and Tom Spurgeon
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Comic Book Nation by Bradford W. Wright
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
The Spirit by Darwyn Cook
This book collects the first six issues of DC’s new line of The Spirit with writing and penciling by Darwyn Cooke and the one-shot Batman/The Spirit written by Cooke and Jeph Loeb with pencils by Cooke. The Spirit was created Will Eisner and originally ran as newspaper insert in the 1930s and 1940s.
I think Cooke handles The Spirit well. To fans, the character is almost as iconic as the likes of Superman. However, Superman has been continually published since his creation with contributions for many writers and artists. The Spirit ceased publication over 50 years ago and has only appeared in reprints. This could pose a problem for some. Do you keep the character historical, do you modernize him, and how do you make it work?
Cooke handles it the way most comics with such long-lasting character do, he ignores it as much as possible. He has kept what is distinctive and great about The Spirit and his supporting cast and simply written and drawn very good new stories.
The Spirit stories are hardboiled detective tales with a touch of superhero adventure and a big dose of humor. The stories cover a wide emotional range, but the tendency is toward the lighthearted. This is in keeping with Eisner’s work and done well by Cooke, who seems to be involved in several detective-oriented comics projects.
Cooke’s drawing style differs from Eisner’s, though I suspect he could imitate Eisner well if he wanted to. Where the new Spirit resembles the old is in it use of design and layout. This is one of those things Eisner brought to The Spirit that made it great and that Cooke does very well. The layout and design element produces two things. First, it results in some stunning and interesting images. Second, and probably more important, it creates a strong integration of image, action and story. This is something all comics should do, but it is done especially in Eisner and Cooke’s Spirit tales. A great example is the first few pages of Batman/The Spirit. A visually interesting device smoothly transitions an opening dialogue to an action sequence. The action builds to an image that cleverly integrates elements from previous frames that is both a dynamic part of the action and static graphic that serves as something like title page. The effect is magnified because it is presented after the turn of a page.
The fans of the original Spirit stories will find much to enjoy in the new ones. For someone unfamiliar with The Spirit, but liking action-filled detective stories, you’ll find some of the finest here.
Saturday, November 15, 2014
Better for All the World by Harry Bruinius
Monday, April 19, 2021
Investigating Lois Lane by Tim Hanley
Lois Lane is one of the most recognized names among superhero comic book characters even though she is not a superhero. The intrepid reporter made has been around for more than 80 years, and her history is recounted by Tim Hanley in Investigating Lois Lane.
Lois was not in the original Superman
stories created by Jerry Siegel
and Joe
Schuster. As they worked and reworked the character, setting and supporting
cast in an attempt to come up with something that would sell, they took
inspiration or the girl reporter movies
of the time to add a love interest for the man of steel. Several popular movies
in the mid-1930s
featured smart, tough, fast-talking, blonde female reporters
such as Torchy
Blane, a character that premiered in 1937’s Smart Blonde.
Schuster’s innovation was to make Lois brunette. He took
inspiration from Jolan
(Joanne) Kovacs, a high school
student in Cleveland
who advertised herself for modeling.
Schuster was apparently smitten with her—she was his model Lois, and all
his other heroines resembled Lois—and they stayed in touch as she moved around
the country pursuing her modeling career. They met up again in New York after
World War
II. He invited her to a ball—even rented a gown for her. Jerry Siegel was
there, too, and she left with him. Siegel left his wife and young son to marry
Kovaks.
Not only was Lois a career woman, an unusual thing when she
premiered with Superman in 1938, she was also
headstrong, cunning, independent and determined to become a top reporter.
However, the writers of Lois’ stories were men; the first Lois Lane story
written by a woman, Tasmyn
O’Flynn, was published in 1982. Though she remained a working woman, she was
often depicted as a damsel in distress or a love-struck cheerleader for
Superman.
Depictions of Lois changed over time as the status of women
changed in American society. Sometimes she was at the forefront, as she briefly
was in the women’s liberation movement during the 1970s. Other time
she lagged and reflecting traditional role for women, or Superman and others
shamed her unfeminine ambition. Too often she was simply a background player in
Superman stories, even though she was more than able to carry a story on her
own in the hands of writers who cared.
Such ups and downs will likely be Lois’ fate for a while. We
can hope that she get the treatment she deserves with stories that let her
shine.
If you’re
interested in this book, you may also be interested in
The
Book of Lies by Brad Meltzer
The
Caped Crusade by Glen Weldon
Comic
Book Nation by Bradford W.
Wright
The
DC Comics Guide to Writing Comics by Dennis O’Neil
Men of
Tomorrow by Gerard Jones
Reading
Comics by Douglas Wolk
The
Secret History of Wonder Woman by Jill Lepore
Seduction
of the Innocent by Max Allan
Collins
Superman
versus the Ku Klux Klan by
Rick Bowers
The
Ten-Cent Plague by David
Hajdu
Hanley, Tim. Investigating
Lois Lane: The Turbulent History of the Daily Planet’s Ace Reporter. Chicago: Chicago
Review Press, 2014.