I wrote this for a class in public administration back in 1997. You can tell it’s for a class because it’s longer than the reviews I’d normally write for this blog. I have the sense from reading it that the assignment must have involve answering particular questions about the book. I got an A-. The hyperlinks are added, but I haven’t changed it otherwise from what I wrote the first time.
Bennis, Warren. On Becoming a Leader. New York: Addison-Wesley, 1994.
Bennis’ premise is that leadership comes out of the state of being of the leader. Leadership starts with a leader’s capacity for self-invention, to shape himself with learning and reflection as opposed to being shaped by circumstances. In Bennis’ words, “No leader sets out to be a leader. People set out to live their lives, expressing themselves fully. When that expression is of value, they become leaders.”
Bennis’ process of self-invention begins with self-knowledge. He proposes four lessons to gaining self-knowledge. First, “you are your own best teacher”; learning is essential. Second is to accept responsibility for your own education. Third, “you can learn anything you want to learn.” Finally, reflection is necessary to develop understanding and a leader must question his experience to learn. Leaders innovate and learn from experience without fear of mistakes. According to Bennis’ definition, a leader is someone in the front, doing things others have not done.
A leader must add knowledge of the world to self-knowledge. Bennis says that a leader should learn about the world through participation rather than reaction. One learns by trying to change something as well as experiencing it as it is. The conscious learner seeks broad experience, learns from others and from mistakes.
A leader must trust his instincts. Bennis uses Emerson’s term “blessed impulse.” Blessed impulse is a tool for making decisions in a world to complex to be completely understood.
Leaders must deploy themselves. By this Bennis means a leader must practice self-expression. Deploying oneself is offset against being deployed by others or the voices of others on one’s head.
Leaders must “get people on their side.” Bennis prescribes constancy, congruity of words and action, reliability and integrity.
Bennis also speaks more generally about the characteristics and roles of leaders. These are similar to what might be found in other books on leadership.
Bennis calls the organization the primary form in American society. He challenges leaders to shape their organizations, and shape society, to make them work in a rapidly changing world. He encourages executives to empower junior leaders in their organizations to teach them leadership through experience.
Throughout, Bennis uses the experience of twelve leaders gleaned from interviews. Bennis includes a brief biography of each leader at the end.
At first, it seems that Bennis says that one becomes a leader by being a leader. This is what he says, but he does not leave the reader hanging. Bennis’ perspective is what is unique about the book. Leadership is the expression of the character, qualities, values and personality of a leader. His is not a direct call for us to become leaders, but for us to become ourselves. Leadership will follow.
This may be a difficult lesson. Buyers of books on leadership are probably more interested in learning the skills of leadership and management to help them in their current situations. Bennis says express yourself. If you are doing what you think you ought to do, if others deploy you, you will not be a leader. Self-expression may take you to something different.
The first step to leadership is self-knowledge. A useful tool is self-evaluation, what Bennis calls “tests and measures.” Bennis offers a set of four tests—really four statements. One could apply the tests with pencil and paper, making lists in response to each statement. Of all the tools and suggestions in the book, this set of tests is the most clear and immediately applicable. A reader wanting to apply Bennis’ lessons would do well to start here.
Little else can be used immediately. Changes in point of view and lifestyle take time. One might argue that only a few Bennis’ suggested activities are specific to developing leadership. To me, much of it sounds fun and interesting. That is the point Bennis is trying to make: leadership comes out of broad experience, education, perspective, desire, mastery of one’s discipline and synthesis of ideas.
My own experience validates this. I am as proud of my single published poem as I am of my accomplishments as an engineer or public servant. The skills and abilities exercised by writing are different from those exercised by engineering. I am persuaded that, though seemingly unrelated, one improves the other in me.
Bennis’ somewhat artificial distinction between managers and leaders is a shortcoming. He makes a manager sound like something one would not want to be. He list skills and characteristics developed from the “education” of a leader and the “training” of a manager. All seemingly undesirable things are on the manager side. On might argue tat several management skills, like deduction and common sense, would be useful to a leader.
Most of the interviews are businessmen, but some come from public service agencies and professions. In may seem that businessmen are more susceptible to “surrendering to the context”—the bottom line, the corporate culture, the style of a boss to be pleased—but public service leaders must face their own context. A public servant may readily accept his organization’s view of the way things should be or done, what is important and who to involve without ever considering his own vision, ability and desire.
It may be more important for public section leadership to use self-expression. While a business leader may have the satisfaction of bringing a product to market, making a profit, even gaining notoriety, a public leader may never see his vision achieved. A public leaders’ satisfaction may have to come from living the life he wants to live.
A particular item addressed by Bennis that may be of use to one in public service is getting people on your side. A public leader may have little to rely on besides his integrity and “voice”—an ability to change the climate of his organization and shape it to work more effectively. As important as it is, Bennis can offer little on the subject except constancy, congruity, reliability and integrity. He says to be someone others might follow. He offers no lessons on persuasion, though if persuasion can be taught, it may be of little benefit to those who lake those characteristics.
If you’re interested in this book, you may also be interested in
The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership Tested by Time by James L. Garlow
Blink by Malcolm Gladwell
Developing the Leader Within by John C. Maxwell
The Difference Maker by John C. Maxwell
Winning with People by John C. Maxwell
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query persuasion. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query persuasion. Sort by date Show all posts
Thursday, December 30, 2010
Thursday, September 13, 2012
Philemon
Philemon. The Holy Bible. New King James Version. Nashville: Thomas Nelson,
1982.
Paul’s letter
to Philemon appears last in most Bibles because it is his shortest epistle. It stands out in other ways. Most of the apostle letters are addressed to
churches rather than to individuals. His
pastoral
letters are directed to individuals who were aides in his ministry, but
they focus on issues of church building.
Philemon is a very personal letter to a
friend addressing a touchy subject. The letter
was delivered at the hands of Onesimus, a runaway slave who probably
stole
some money
when he took flight from Philemon’s home.
Onesimus ended up seeking out Paul in Rome. Under the apostle’s teaching he became a Christian.
So what is the right thing to do? Paul wrote a lot about the importance of authority
and of submitting to civil laws. He also wrote about the essential equality of
all Christians, including free people and slaves, and by extension the equality
of all people. Paul does both. He respected authority by sending Onesimus
home to his master. He appealed to
Philemon’s Christian ethic
by sending the letter asking him to forgive the slave, now a brother in Christ,
and to free him.
This little letter is rich with lessons
in Christian ethics, firm teaching,
gentle persuasion, and friendship. It is hard to write about it without going on
longer than the letter itself.
Paul also wrote
Google
Sunday, April 12, 2015
Esther
Esther
is one of the most famous people from the Old Testament.
The story of her life, as told in the Biblical book
bearing her name, has been adapted to the stage and film.
Joan Collins
played her in Esther and the King (1960); Tiffany
Dupont played her in One Night with the King (2006)
based on the novel by Tommy Tenney.
In 2013,
Jen Lilley
played the role in The Book of Esther.
It is easy to see why the book has captured the interest of
storytellers in several media. It has court
intrigues, romance,
poetic justice,
a beauty
pageant, culture
clashes, political
and religious
oppression,
just to name a few elements a storyteller or reader of almost any persuasion
might latch onto. You can bring many viewpoints to this book and carry many interpretations
from it, though the book also provides its own interpretation.
Esther takes place during the reign of the Persian King Ahasuerus
(generally identified as Xerxes I). He
puts aside his wife, Queen Vashti, and his
princes arrange an elaborate campaign to find a replacement. Esther is forcibly
recruited into the competition. Esther is a Jewish woman, a ward of
her relative
Mordecai,
who serves in Ahasuerus’ court. He secretly advises her, her humility and kindness win
her favor in with the head caretaker of the harem, and her beauty wins the
king. Meanwhile, Haman,
a high official who has come to hate Mordecai, hatches a plan to destroy the
Jewish people through the empire. Esther risks her life to appeal to the king
and thwart Haman’s plan. This summary hardly does justice to the story, though
even in the Bible the style is plain.
These events are the genesis of the Jewish festival of Purim. This is
where the internal interpretation of the book comes in. Esther is celebrated
for her courage
to act. In addition to that, the hand of God, who is barely
mentioned in the book, is seen throughout the events. He puts someone in place
to rescue the Jewish captives from their enemies. He elevates Esther and
Mordecai to give them protection while they are under the rule of foreigners.
Though the people were threatened with genocide, God
used the situation to preserve them and possibly even set up their eventual
return to their homeland.
The historical
books of the Bible are generally written in a plain, narrative style, though it
occasionally records songs or
other literary forms. Esther stands out in that it is almost novelistic. The conflict
escalates to a climax
followed by a brief denouement.
This makes it a very engaging book.
If you’re interested in this book, you may also be interested in
Monday, December 10, 2012
Quiet by Susan Cain
I am an introvert. So is Susan Cain,
author of Quiet. I imagine so are many of the other readers
of this book
on introversion
and its strengths as they look to understand themselves and live more
comfortably in a world the favors the outgoing.
Cain divides her book into four parts corresponding to four questions
about introversion. What are the roots
of the preference for extroversion
in the West,
especially in America? Is introversion real, a quality inherent to
our nature? Are there cultures where
introversion is preferred? Finally, how
to introvert live in an extroverted culture?
What Cain calls the “Extrovert
Ideal” arose with a cultural shift to a focus on personality. This isn’t personality
as a trait as she uses in the rest of the book, but personality as personal forcefulness, persuasion
and salesmanship. This seems to have arisen naturally over time
with the rise of industry
and our move to cities. We were less producers and more sellers, and
the main thing we had to sell was ourselves.
Cain uses as an example, though the trend started earlier, Dale Carnegie
(a Missourian
like me). Carnegie propelled himself
from shy farm boy to dynamic people person by mastering public
speaking and he built and business
that still exists today on teaching people to be more outgoing.
The distinction between introversion and extroversion is more that
cultural, though. There is evidence that
inborn physiological
difference play a role in these personalities.
Cain discusses research on the subject that suggest there is a biological basis
that at least partly explains
introversion, though life experience likely still plays some role. There is not a 100 percent correlation
between being a “highly reactive” or “highly sensitive” person and being an
introvert, but many introverts reading this book will probably recognize
themselves in these categories.
Though the Extrovert Ideal prevails in the West, introversion seems to
be preferred in the East. We see this in the quiet studiousness that
has become the reputation of Asian-Americans. Many Asian cultures
prefer quiet, reserve, deference, reflectiveness
and other traits associated with introversion.
They are seen as wisdom, politeness and respect.
Though extroverts draw most of the attention, and that will likely
continue, introverts have strengths that can be useful in organization and
society (introverts aren’t antisocial, they just deal with stimulus differently
than extroverts). Introverts are more
likely to pay attention to warning signs.
For instance, Warren Buffet
predicted the collapse of the internet bubble.
He wasn’t being a bearish pessimist; he was just paying attention to
signs that reward-hungry extroverts were ignoring. Cain found her questioning mind and quiet
demeanor made her an excellent negotiator because she could question assertions
without seeming overly aggressive. I’ve
often found myself in the role of mediator and negotiator for the same reason;
I could listen, sort out what people really wanted, and offer a compromise.
Not only that, Cain offers a path for happy introversion. We can be true to ourselves and be as
extroverted as we need to be to accomplish those things that are truly
important to us. Extroverts can be as
quiet as they need to be, too.
Reading Quiet prompted me to
think a lot about my introversion. With
a few exceptions (I was never especially afraid of public speaking—it got me
out of the crowd of pressing bodies in the audience), I’m a typical
introvert. I may write about
it sometime. I suspect many introverts
who read it will find much to reflect on, especially since such reflection will
come naturally. It is a worthy book for
extroverts, too, for insight into the many obvious and hidden introverts in
their lives, probably a few very close to them.
Cain, Susan. Quiet: The Power if Introverts in a World
That Can’t Stop Talking. New York: Crown, 2012.
Google
Saturday, November 15, 2014
Better for All the World by Harry Bruinius
Harry
Bruinius takes the title of his book, Better
for All the World, from a quote from famous United States
Supreme
Court Justice Oliver
Wendell Holmes, Jr. In his opinion,
written for a court majority that authorized states to forcibly sterilize some
people, Holmes expressed the notion that it was better to sterilize a defective
person than to permit them to have defective children who may place greater
burden on government
systems for justice
and welfare.
This legal
justification for forced sterilization was just one of the policy
victories of the eugenics
movement in the America.
Eugenicists were also influential in establishing state marriage
laws and
federal immigration quotas and restrictions.
Even from its start, notions of social
engineering and politics
tinged the science
of eugenics. Francis
Galton coined the word that applied to both the study of heredity and the
improvement of humanity through selective breeding over generations. Galton
established the field based on concepts from his cousin Charles
Darwin’s books on evolution, Gregor Mendel’s
studies of plant heredity, and his own statistical
studies of human characteristics. Though he mostly kept these speculations to
himself, he considered the possibility of improving humans through breeding
just as farmers improved plants and livestock.
American reformers of all political persuasion welcomed Galton’s ideas;
they were looking for reliable, scientific means of tackling poverty and crime.
Galton’s method were used to study families and supposedly proved that traits
related to poverty, criminality, low intelligence,
and the harder to recognize (therefore more dangerous) feeblemindedness. These
studies also uncover a troubling pairing in females of feeblemindedness and
fecundity. The implication was that the good stock of moral, productive
Americans risked overrun by a class of hereditary degenerates. America’s best
needed to produce larger family, and its poor and feebleminded needed to be
restrained from passing on their inferior traits.
Much of Bruinius’ book focuses on this American eugenics movement.
Representing leadership in the scientific community is Charles
Davenport. He popularized the work of Galton, convinced the Carnegie
Institute to fund a station to study eugenics, and did research that
contributed to the early development of genetics.
Representing the bridge between science and policy is Harry
Laughlin. A Missourian
and a protégé of Davenport, his reports and advice to Congress helped
to inform restrictive immigration policy and support state programs of forced
sterilization of convicts and the feebleminded, ultimately upheld in by the Supreme
Court, as previously mentioned, in the case of Buck vs. Bell.
The development of eugenics policy in the U.S. was being watched
overseas. In particularly, racial purity laws enacted by the Nazis in Germany
explicitly cited American research and legal precedents. Many reformers in
America and elsewhere were gratified by the apparent success of eugenics
policies in Germany.
Even as it was reaching its peak as a political reform movement,
laboratory science was undermining eugenics. Laboratory studies of the
mechanisms of heredity, which had discovered chromosomes by the 1930s, were
showing that heredity and the expression of traits, especially moral or personality
traits, were much more complicated and harder to predict than the eugenicists
assumed. Through its association with the Nazis, eugenics became wholly
discredited in the public mind, though its effects lingered in American
policies for decades.
Our understanding of genetics and heredity has improved a lot.
Biotechnology has made a new kind of genetic engineering possible. The
eugenicist dreams of eliminating disease and creating better people in future
generations is more attainable than ever, at least in limited ways.
If this puts our evolution in our hands, are we ethically
and morally evolved enough to use this power? Are humans intelligent animals or
are we unique creatures? Are human rights
inalienable characteristics of human beings, or are they social constructs,
ideas that can rise, fade, or change like other ideas? How does the good of the
species relate to the good of the individual? What does it mean to be a parent?
The way we answer these questions, and other related to the implications of our
science and technology,
will establish what kind of people we are, and possibly the destiny of
generations to come.
If you’re interested in this book, you may also be interested in
Bruinius, Harry. Better for All
the World: The Secret History of Forced Sterilization and America’s Quest for
Racial Purity. New York: Alfred A.
Knopf, 2006.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)